Customize - Urban Dictionary Store

Pro Customization

Create unique products with your own words and definitions

Preview

Personalize Your Design

Your Word

Your Definition

Latin, "where is the benefit?" A type of logical fallacy in which one claims one didn't do something bad because it was not in one's interests to do so.   An example would be, "Why would I steal from the cash register?  [It's going] to hurt the business if I do, and then I might lose my job."

The argument is usually used on behalf of someone else: for example, Ludo Martens (1995) argues that Stalin could not possibly have massacred millions of Russians because he needed them to fight WW2; Fogel & Engermann claimed* that American slavery was not very bad because it was in the [best interests] of slaveowners to have content slaves.

The argument is a fallacy because it assumes that all relevant motives of the actor are well-established, and lead away from the act.  It does not account for motives like personal [hatred], shame, fear, spite, ideology, and so on.
________________________
* In *Time [on the Cross]* (1971); the book was conclusively debunked by David & Stampp, *Reckoning with Slavery* (1976).

Text fits

Menu

Pro Customization

Preview

Personalize Your Design

Shopping Assistant