Customize - Urban Dictionary Store

Pro Customization

Create unique products with your own words and definitions

Preview

Personalize Your Design

Your Word

Your Definition

A portmanteau of [Argumentum Ad Argumentum] and Bulverism, this rhetorical fallacy combines circular reasoning, the genetic fallacy, and argument-labeling with presumption and condescension. The Argumenterist presumes that a speaker's argument is false or invalid without engaging its content, then explains why the argument is being made by attacking its perceived category, motives, or origins—even if the argument might actually be correct. Classic moves: "This is just relativism," "That's postmodernism," "This is pseudoscience," "This is bullshit," "That's an ad hominem fallacy" (while committing [one]), "This is hasty generalization" (without showing the haste). The fallacy is circular because the presumption of falsity justifies the dismissal, and the dismissal confirms the presumption. It's genetic because it traces the argument to supposedly disreputable origins (relativism, postmodernism, etc.). And it's condescending because the Argumenterist speaks from above, diagnosing the argument's pathologies rather than engaging its substance. Argumenterism is the intellectual's version of sticking fingers in ears—it sounds [sophisticated] because you're using [philosophical] vocabulary, but you're still not listening.

Text may be too long

Menu

Pro Customization

Preview

Personalize Your Design

Shopping Assistant